It’s difficult to find professional-quality polymer clay suppliers in Canada.
My supplier (MacPherson) switched from Prosculpt to Living Doll polymer clay earlier this year.
“They are made by the same company (Sculpey) and they’re very similar. The formula is basically the same for both clays. You’ll love it!” the suppier assures me.
Yeah, no.
Maybe the first bar of Living Doll that I’ve opened is just unfortunately flawed, but so far I don’t like it at all. The texture is smoother and stickier than Prosculpt—this means that I lose details very easily, and that the clay practically melts as you work it. Sure, with Prosculpt I often have to breathe on the clay to warm it up and keep it workable, but it’s a technique that I enjoy—I like to think I’m breathing some life into my work. Living Doll is just a struggle to shape, let alone giving it life.
Fingers stick together, ears smush, bottoms flatten. Like Primo, Living Doll has a rubbery sort of quality that makes it difficult to add tiny details (it’s like tiny impressions in the clay bounce back out instead of staying the way you want them) and that makes it difficult to smooth pieces together seamlessly without ruining prior details. Granted, it’s not as bad as resistent as FIMO, and it stays softer than Primo, but it is not fun to work with.
I’ve only baked one Living Doll sculpture so far, so I can’t comment extensivley on the cured quality. I did find that the clay darkened more significantly than prosculpt. I believe it stays a bit more pliable and so it may be more resistent to breaks. It has more of a translucent quality to it than Prosculpt, but I found that this made it more prone to moonies (tiny cracks that are usually shaped like crescent moons) and made it more difficult to keep the armature invisible in wrists and other narrowed parts.
I’ve got 4 bars of Living Doll in total, and less than a quarter bar of Prosculpt left. I’ve also got a show in less than a month, and Christmas orders coming in. It looks like I will have to find a new supplier for Prosculpt. I’ve got nothing against Macpherson—they are wonderful, and have the best costomer service I have ever experienced, hands down. I’ll keep the Living Doll and try to get used to working with it—its qualities open it up for new and different projects. But it just isn’t what I need for my current work.